1950

Jim LaRock; Second at 165 pounds

 

1953

Jim Howard; Third at 130 pounds

 

1954

Jim Howard; Second at 130 pounds

 

1959

Bob Marella; Second at heavyweight

 

1960

Jack Stanbro; Second at 191 pounds

 

1969

Terry Habecker; Fourth at 137 pounds

 

1974

Paul Iacovelli; Fourth at 190 pounds

 

1975

Ron King; Sixth at 177 pounds

 

1979

Ralph Salem; Sixth at 177 pounds

 

1983

Bart Morrow; Fifth at 134 pounds

Bob Panariello; Fourth at 118 pounds

 

1984

Glenn Cogswell; Fourth at 126 pounds

Bill Condon; Eighth at 190 pounds

Dave Kittay; Third at 177 pounds

Bart Morrow; Second at 134 pounds

Bob Panariello; Second at 118 pounds

 

1985

Dave Kittay; Third at 177 pounds

Bart Morrow; Second at 134 pounds

 

1986

Glenn Cogswell; Fifth at 126 pounds

Steve Hile; Second at 167 pounds

Rich Kane; Fourth at heavyweight

Pete Mankowich; Fourth at 142 pounds

Paul Schumann; Sixth at 118 pounds

 

1987

Bob Panariello; Third at 118 pounds

Tom Mankowich; Sixth at 158 pounds

 

1988

Dan Bieller; Fifth at 177 pounds

Tim Cotter; Sixth at 134 pounds

Mike Cronmiller; First at 158 pounds

Mike Fusilli; Sixth at 190 pounds

Marty Nichols; Sixth at 150 pounds

Rich Kane; Eighth at heavyweight

 

1989

Dan Bieller; Second at 177 pounds

Mike Fusilli; Second at 190 pounds

Ron Gross; Second at 142 pounds

Joel Lamson; Fifth at 126 pounds

Marty Nichols; Fifth at 150 pounds

 

 

1990

Mike Cronmiller; Third at 158 pounds

Mike Fusilli; First at heavyweight

Ron Gross; Fifth at 142 pounds

Joel Lamson; Second at 126 pounds

Marty Nichols; Second at 150 pounds

 

1991

Bill Hadsell; Eighth at 190 pounds

 

1992

Lenny Bruehwiler; Sixth at 134 pounds

Kent Maslin, Sixth at 142 pounds

Chris Matteotti; Seventh at 118 pounds

Mike Murtha; Seventh at 177 pounds

Dan Uhteg; Fourth at 190 pounds

 

1993

Steve Farr; Third at 190 pounds

Kent Maslin; Fifth at 142 pounds

Mike Murtha; Third at 177 pounds

Matt Sorochinsky; Third at 158 pounds

 

1994

Steve Farr; First at 190 pounds

Kent Maslin; Second at 150 pounds

Chris Matteotti; Fourth at 118 pounds

Mike Murtha; Fifth at 177 pounds

Matt Sorochinsky; Second at 158 pounds

 

1995

Jason Bovenzi; First at 190 pounds

Chris Matteotti; First at 118 pounds

Ben Weiland; Seventh at 177 pounds

 

1996

John Gemmell; Second at 118 pounds

 

1997

John Gemmell; Second at 118 pounds

 

1998

John Gemmell; First at 126 pounds

 

1999

Tommy Hall; Fourth at 133 pounds

 

2000

Ryan Ciotoli; Second at 157 pounds

Felix Martinez; Sixth at 125 pounds

 

2001

Ryan Ciotoli; Second at 157 pounds

Carlos Restrepo; Fourth at 125 pounds

 

2002

Ryan Ciotoli; Sixth at 157 pounds

Tommy Hall; First at 133 pounds

Marc Israel; Eighth at 141 pounds

Carlos Restrepo; Second at 125 pounds

 

2003

Jeff Edelstein; Eighth at 184 pounds

Bill Parry; Seventh at 165 pounds

 

2004

KC Beach; Seventh at 157 pounds

 

2005

KC Beach; Seventh at 157 pounds

Marc Israel; Third at 165 pounds

2006
Jad Duca; Seventh at 157 pounds
Matthias Keib; Fifth at 174 pounds
Robert Stubbs; Eighth at 184 pounds

All-American recognition is earned by placing among the top eight at the NCAA championships. Before 1967 all colleges competed in one division. From 1967-73 Ithaca competed at the NCAA College Division championships. Since 1973 Ithaca has competed at the NCAA Division III championships.