| 5
| | Jenna Williams
| UT | 5-7 | Fr.
| Northborough, Mass. / Algonquin Regional |
| 6
| | Brittany Lillie
| P/OF | 5-7 | Jr.
| Honeoye Falls / Honeoye Falls-Lima |
| 7
| | Adrienne Walters
| 2B/OF | 5-2 | Fr.
| Solon, Ohio / Solon |
| 8
| C | Allison Greaney
| 3B/P | 5-5 | Jr.
| Iselin, N.J. / John F. Kennedy |
| 9
| | Jennifer Biondi
| SS/2B | 5-5 | Fr.
| Denville, N.J. / Morris Knolls |
| 10
| | Molly O'Donnell
| 3B/1B | 5-8 | Fr.
| Niskayuna / Niskayuna |
| 11
| | Julianna Van Meter
| OF | 5-5 | So.
| Rome / Rome Free Academy |
| 12
| | Jamie LeFebvre
| OF | 5-7 | Fr.
| Demarest, N.J. / NVRHS Demarest |
| 13
| | Alyssa Brook
| P | 5-9 | Sr.
| Tinton Falls, N.J. / Monmouth Regional |
| 14
| | Annmarie Forenza
| SS/OF | 5-6 | So.
| Whitehouse Station, N.J. / Hunterdon Central |
| 15
| | Caitlin Ryan
| 1B | 5-7 | Sr.
| Clarksburg, N.J. / Allentown |
| 16
| | Erinn Jacobi
| C | 5-4 | So.
| Penfield / Penfield |
| 17
| | Katherine Wilson
| OF/C | 5-3 | Sr.
| Sparta, N.J. / Sparta |
| 18
| | Meghan Kissinger
| OF/2B | 5-5 | Fr.
| Havertown, Pa. / Country Day |
| 19
| | Kait Dolan
| 2B/OF | 5-7 | Jr.
| Farmington / Victor |
| 21
| | Alyssa Guzman
| OF | 5-3 | Sr.
| Newburgh / Newburgh Free Academy |
| 22
| | Kerry Barger
| C | 5-6 | Jr.
| Carmel / Carmel |
| 23
| | Becca Salant
| 3B | 5-4 | Fr.
| Holliston, Mass. / Holliston |
| 25
| | Courtney Noster
| DP/1B | 5-8 | Jr.
| Lorain, Ohio / Clearview |
| 26
| | Lindsey Johnson
| C | 5-5 | Fr.
| Penfield / Penfield |
| 27
| | Carianne D'Alessandro
| 1B | 5-7 | Fr.
| Bound Brook, N.J. / Bridgewater-Raritan |
| 28
| | Brooke Kithcart
| P | 5-11 | Sr.
| Slate Hill / Minisink Valley |